the risk of ‘Over-Punishment’

Laurie Garduque

Laurie Garduque

It’s a “dangerous myth” to trust that releasing jail inmates due to the pandemic is increasing criminal activity, Laurie Garduque of the MacArthur Foundation writes into the Washington Post.

Garduque cites a JFA Institute report concluding that brand-new reform methods have actually paid off jail populations whilst not influencing criminal activity.

“Over-punishing men and women at low threat of committing even more crimes converts them into individuals at high risk of committing even more crimes,” Garduque states.

It’s in addition a myth that protests for racial justice tend to be causing a crime boost, she adds.

Violent criminal activity rates fell from 2019 to 2020 in more than 1 / 2 of the 25 largest U.S. cities.

Lawyer General William Barr states reform efforts are “pushing many America’s urban centers straight back toward a far more dangerous last.”

But Garduque counters that studies have shown that “tough” techniques tend to be a waste of resources.

Strategies such as stop-and-frisk additionally the overuse of jails are discriminatory nor hold communities safe, she writes.

In the place of being “tough on criminal activity,” buying the needs of town is more effective, she says.

With regards to reports of criminal activity up this present year in many locations, Garduque states, “Year-to-year crime stats usually do not decorate the most accurate image; styles over decades do.”

She highlights that the existing surge in certain crimes — including, the present jump in homicides in metropolitan areas —ignores the fact overall criminal activity, including violent criminal activity and homicides, is somewhat lower than in the 1980s and 1990s.

An uptick or downturn within one 12 months does not fundamentally signal a larger trend, states Garduque,

Noting that some policymakers think twice to attempt unlawful justice reforms because they seem also brand new, nuanced or radical, she writes that urban centers and counties have-been applying tested, data-driven reforms that keep communities safe while decreasing the overuse of jails.

This can include bail reform, that has not already been found to increase criminal activity, based on a Chicago research.

Extra reading: Detroit Chief says COVID-19 Jail Releases Boost Crime

Latest posts