Are Jail Releases Police Protests Causing Crime?

It is a “dangerous myth” to trust that releasing prison inmates due to the pandemic is increasing criminal activity, Laurie Garduque for the MacArthur Foundation writes in Washington article. Garduque alludes to a JFA Institute report finishing that new reform strategies have decreased jail communities while not influencing criminal activity. “Over-punishing men and women at low threat of committing more crimes transforms them into folks at risky of committing even more crimes,” Garduque says. It’s also a myth that protests for racial justice are causing a crime increase, she says. Violent criminal activity prices fell from 2019 to 2020 in more than 1 / 2 of the 25 largest U.S. metropolitan areas. lawyer General William Barr has said reform attempts are “pushing numerous America’s towns back toward a far more dangerous past.” Garduque states research has shown that “tough” techniques tend to be a waste of resources. Tactics such stop-and-frisk and the overuse of jails are discriminatory and never hold communities safe. As opposed to being “tough on crime,” purchasing the requirements of the community is more effective, she says.

With regards to reports of crime up this present year in several locations, Garduque states, “Year-to-year criminal activity stats cannot color the most precise image; trends over years do. Pointing to a current increase in a few crimes — for instance, the recent jump in homicides in locations ignores that total criminal activity, including violent crime and homicides, is substantially less than in the 1980s and 1990s. An uptick or downturn within one 12 months doesn’t fundamentally signal a larger trend. Some frontrunners hesitate on criminal justice reforms since they seem also brand-new, nuanced or radical. Cities and counties being applying tested, data-driven reforms that keep communities safe while decreasing the overuse of jails, states Garduque. This includes bail reform, that has not been found to boost crime.

Latest posts